Party Tray

Reorder Menu Items

Drag and drop items to change their display order within each category

Cancel
Assorted Cookies

Items can appear in multiple categories. Reordering within one category doesn't affect other categories. Click "Save Order" when you're done.

Cookies with Coping Skills
Because some feelings are best handled one bite at a time.
  • Mixed Emotion Cookies
    Peanut Butter M&M, pretzels and Oreo’s…for when you can’t decide if you are feeling sweet or salty!
    GF
    Order: 0
  • Ritz Cracker Cookies
    Sometimes you are feeling salty and need a little crunch
    Order: 0
  • Brownie Cookies
    When you can't commit — and that's okay.
    Order: 1
  • Caramel M&M Cookies
    Colorful coping mechanisms.
    Order: 2
  • Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies
    Old-school comfort for new-age chaos.
    Order: 3
  • Potato Chip Cookies (GF/DF)
    Snack attack meets soft landing.
    GF DF
    Order: 5
  • Salted Caramel Cookies
    Salted Caramel Cookies
    Sweet comfort with a pinch of reality.
    Order: 6
  • Raspberry Almond Thumbprint Cookies
    For when you're feeling a little sentimental (and snacky).
    Order: 7
  • Chocolate Chip Meringue Cookies
    Crispy, airy, and emotionally unstable (in a cute way).
    Order: 8
Bars for Big Feelings
Because you deserve something solid when life feels gooey.
  • Milk Pie Bars
    If nostalgia were a dessert, this would be it. Creamy, dreamy milk pie bars that feel like a deep exhale, a cozy blanket, and zero emotional processing—just vibes.
    GF
    Order: 0
  • Ooey Gooey Butter Bars
    For when you need a hug… but in bar form.
    Order: 0
  • Pretzel Caramel Brownie Bars
    Sweet. Salty. Fudgy. Crunchy. Basically group therapy in bar form.
    Order: 0
  • Oatmeal Caramel Chocolate Chip Bars (GF)
    Wholesome on the outside. Melty on the inside. Just like you.
    GF
    Order: 1
  • Brown Sugar Meringue Shortbread Bars
    Two layers of sweetness — and none of them chill.
    Order: 2
  • Candy Bar Cookie Bars
    All your cravings, one convenient crisis.
    Order: 3
  • Oatmeal Raspberry Bars
    Wholesome meets "I need a treat right now."
    Order: 4
  • Slutty Brownies
    For when your self-control takes a day off.
    Order: 5
Cup-fuls of Comfort
Tiny bites. Big emotions.
  • Buckeye Cups
    Because some days call for peanut butter therapy.
    Order: 0
  • S'mores Cups (GF)
    For when your feelings get a little toasty.
    GF
    Order: 1
Therapy, but Make It Cake
Because frosting fixes (almost) everything.
  • Carrot Cake Slices
    Because vegetables count when they're covered in cream cheese frosting.
    Order: 0
  • Surprise Torte
    Layers of mystery, topped with whipped feelings.
    Order: 1
Self-Care Loaves
Because you can't pour from an empty bread pan.
  • Banana Chocolate Chip Bread
    Perfect for mornings when your motivation's still ripening.
    Order: 0
  • Zucchini Bread
    Self-care disguised as vegetables.
    Order: 1
  • Corn Muffins
    Southern comfort for northern meltdowns.
    Order: 2
Inner Child Snacks
Therapy for the part of you that still loves sprinkles.
  • Pop-Tarts (Cinnamon, Strawberry, Blueberry)
    Therapy for your inner child — fully frosted.
    Order: 0
  • Krispie Treats
    Crispy. Chewy. Childlike wonder included.
    Order: 1
  • Buckeye Krispie Treats
    Rice Krispies, reimagined for your emotional support pantry.
    Order: 2
  • Iced Sugar Cookies
    Because you deserve a birthday party whenever you say so. Can be made allergen friendly with vanilla flavor or my favorite almond flavored!
    Order: 3
Sophisticated Snackers
For refined palates and dramatic inner monologues.
  • Marzipan/Dark Chocolate Mandelbread
    Old soul energy with a sweet edge.
    Order: 0
  • Marzipan Raspberry Hamantaschen Cookies
    For when you want to feel fancy and seen.
    Order: 1
  • Hamantaschen (Cinnamon, Lemon or Chocolate)
    Triangle-shaped joy for your next identity crisis.
    Order: 2
  • Biscoff Cookie Sandwiches
    Because sometimes you just need a cookie that gets you.
    Order: 3
  • Nilla Cookie Sandwiches
    Basically emotional support whoopie pies.
    Order: 4
  • Dipped Palmiers
    For when you're feeling a little flaky (but lovable).
    Order: 5
Sweet Escapism
For when you just need something that understands.
  • Apple Cider Cinnamon Pastry Bites
    These apple cider cinnamon pastry bites taste like sweater weather and pretending your to-do list doesn’t exist. Soft, spiced, and cozy enough to calm even the loudest thoughts.
    GF
    Order: 0
  • Babka Bites
    These babka bites are what Grandma would hand you before saying, “Sit down and tell me everything.” Soft, buttery, and swirled with rich filling, they’re made for moments when comfort comes first and feelings can wait their turn.
    GF
    Order: 0
  • Everything Bark
    A little bit of everything — just like your mood.
    Order: 0
  • Truffles (Caramel Brownie, Mint Chip, Iced Animal Cracker, Birthday Cake)
    Tiny bites. Big feelings.
    Order: 1
  • Caramel White Chocolate Dipped Pretzel Sticks
    Because balance is salty-sweet (and dipped).
    Order: 2
GF Goodies That Get You
All the feelings, none of the gluten.
  • Apple Cider Cinnamon Pastry Bites
    These apple cider cinnamon pastry bites taste like sweater weather and pretending your to-do list doesn’t exist. Soft, spiced, and cozy enough to calm even the loudest thoughts.
    GF
    Order: 0
  • Milk Pie Bars
    If nostalgia were a dessert, this would be it. Creamy, dreamy milk pie bars that feel like a deep exhale, a cozy blanket, and zero emotional processing—just vibes.
    GF
    Order: 0
  • Sugar Cookies (GF)
    For when you want to keep it simple — emotionally and ingredient-wise.
    GF
    Order: 0
  • Oatmeal Caramel Chocolate Chip Bars (GF)
    Wholesome on the outside. Melty on the inside. Just like you.
    GF
    Order: 1
  • S'mores Cups (GF)
    For when your feelings get a little toasty.
    GF
    Order: 1
  • Potato Chip Cookies (GF/DF)
    Snack attack meets soft landing.
    GF DF
    Order: 5
Back to Menu Items